Peanut Butter Whiskey: A Heavenly Blend for Cocktails




Peanut Butter Whiskey

Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

I’ll never forget the first time I tried a peanut butter whiskey cocktail. It was at a friend’s dinner party, and they served a drink called “The Elvis” – peanut butter whiskey, banana liqueur and cream. I was sceptical at first, but that first sip was a revelation…the rich, nutty flavour of the whiskey blended perfectly with the sweet banana and velvety texture of the cream. I was hooked!

Since that fateful party, peanut butter whiskey has become a staple in my home bar lineup and cocktail repertoire. Keep reading as I break down everything you need to know about this versatile spirit. Trust me, after you learn about peanut butter whiskey’s origins, flavours, best cocktail recipes and food pairings, you’ll want to stock up your bar too!

A Brief History of Peanut Butter Whiskey

Peanut butter whiskey is relatively new on the spirits scene, first gaining popularity in the 2010s as craft distilleries experimented with flavour infusions.

Some key events in peanut butter whiskey history:

  • 2008 – Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey launched in California, credited as one of the earliest commercially available peanut butter whiskeys
  • 2010’s – Multiple small-batch distilleries start experimenting with peanut butter flavours
  • 2015 – Sales start seeing rapid growth as the flavour gains viral popularity
  • 2019 – Over 50,000 cases sold in the US that year alone

What makes peanut butter whiskey stand out from other flavoured spirits is how the flavour is achieved. While some liqueurs and vodkas rely on sugary syrups for flavour, the best peanut butter whiskeys start with a quality, full-bodied whiskey as the base spirit. That whiskey is then expertly blended with real peanut butter, resulting in a rich, nuanced flavour profile.

Most peanut butter whiskeys today are made in the US, though the trend is catching on globally as well. No matter its origins, one thing is consistent across all quality peanut butter whiskeys: the smooth, indulgent flavour that takes cocktails to the next level.

Peanut Butter Whiskey

Peanut butter whiskey has seen tremendous growth in popularity over the past decade.

What Makes It So Unique?

So what exactly gives peanut butter whiskey its signature flavour? Here are the key characteristics that set it apart:

A Harmonious Blend of Rich Ingredients

At its core, peanut butter whiskey brings together two ultra-rich ingredients:

  • Peanut Butter – Only the highest quality, fresh ground peanut butter cuts. This ensures the creamy, nutty peanut flavour shines through brightly.
  • Whiskey – The whiskey base tends to be a bolder, full-flavoured variety like bourbon or rye to stand up to the peanut butter. The richness of the whiskey balances beautifully with the nutty sweetness.

When artfully blended by expert distillers, the result is a spirit with layers of flavour – the roasted nuttiness from the peanut butter, spicy oak notes from the whiskey, and a long, smooth caramel/vanilla finish.

Also Read: Unveiling the Best Whiskey for Christmas: A Gift Guide for the Discerning Palate

Perfectly Balanced Sweetness

Despite having peanut butter as a dominant flavour, the best peanut butter whiskeys avoid being overly sweet or cloying. Professional tasters describe the perfect balance as “just sweet enough.”

Distillers carefully select the sugars and quantities used to complement the peanut and whiskey flavours instead of overpowering them. This balance allows the flavours to shine both straight and in cocktails.

Remarkable Versatility

From classic whiskey cocktails to decadent dessert drinks and beyond, peanut butter whiskey proves endlessly adaptable. Its balanced flavour profile layers beautifully with other ingredients without dominating the drink.

In the hands of skilled mixologists, peanut butter whiskey elevates countless cocktail recipes. It also shines beautifully on its own served straight up or over ice. However you drink it, peanut butter whiskey always satisfies.

Peanut Butter Whiskey

Peanut butter whiskey brings remarkable versatility to cocktails.

Now that you know what makes this spirit so special, let’s look at how to make classic peanut butter whiskey cocktails at home.

Crafting the Perfect Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktail

Getting the perfect balance of flavours is key when crafting peanut butter whiskey cocktails. Here is a foolproof recipe for the classic PB Whiskey Sour:



  1. Add all ingredients except bitters to a cocktail shaker filled with ice
  2. Shake vigorously for 20-30 seconds until chilled and frothy
  3. Strain into a rock glass over fresh ice
  4. Garnish with 4-5 dashes of peanut butter bitters (optional)

For this basic template, feel free to experiment with different styles of whiskey as the base spirit such as bourbon, rye or Irish. I also sometimes add 0.25 oz orange liqueur for extra fruitiness.

And don’t stop at the whiskey sour! Peanut butter whiskey makes classic cocktails like Old Fashioneds, Manhattans and even Negronis extra crave-worthy. See the recipes below.<!— Insert comparison table —>

CocktailBase SpiritMixersGarnish
Peanut Butter Old FashionedBourbonBrown sugar, BittersOrange peel
Peanut Butter ManhattanRyeSweet Vermouth, BittersCocktail cherry
Peanut Butter NegroniGinSweet Vermouth, CampariOrange peel

The possibilities are endless when you use peanut butter whiskey as a building block. Now let’s look beyond the classics at some elevated, creative options.

Elevated Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails

Once you master the classic PB whiskey cocktails, it’s time to get creative. Peanut Butter whiskey effortlessly enhances decadent flavours like chocolate, coffee, fall spices and more.

Here are a few of my favourite elevated versions to mix up for your next cocktail party:

Nutty Russian

Rich coffee liqueur and velvety half-and-half complement the peanut butter whiskey beautifully. Garnish with chocolate for extra decadence.

PB Cinnamon Swirl

Warming cinnamon notes blend flawlessly with the nutty whiskey and sweet cream liqueur.

Chocolate Covered Cherry

It’s like a grown-up chocolate-covered cherry! Sweet cherry brandy and rich chocolate make this cocktail dangerously delicious.

When working with such bold flavours, subtle additions like a dash of salt or bitter liqueurs like Campari help balance the sweetness. Spices like cinnamon, nutmeg and vanilla also integrate seamlessly.

Peanut Butter Whiskey

An elevated peanut butter Old Fashioned cocktail. Image by Gerrie van der Walt on Unsplash

Now that you’re equipped with cocktail recipes galore, let’s explore pairing peanut butter whiskey creations with food.

Pairing Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails with Food

In addition to shining brightly on their own, peanut butter whiskey cocktails pair remarkably well with certain flavours and textures of food too.

Here are my favourite pairings to try at your next dinner party:

For Appetizers

Balance out salty flavours by pairing cocktails featuring peanut butter whiskey with apps like:

  • Smoky grilled chicken wings
  • Crunchy pretzels with a creamy peanut butter honey mustard dipping sauce
  • Bacon jalapeño poppers

The sweet nuttiness and whiskey spice cut through salty and savoury flavours perfectly.

For Main Dishes

Hearty mains like fried chicken, burgers, ribs and steaks stand up well to peanut butter whiskey’s rich profile:

  • Buttermilk fried chicken with spicy maple glaze
  • Gourmet burgers with all the fixings
  • Fall-off-the-bone barbecue ribs
  • Expertly grilled ribeye steak

The subtle sweet flavours won’t overpower meaty dishes and instead, complement them.

For Desserts

Finally, satisfy your sweet tooth by pairing peanutty cocktails with indulgent desserts like:

  • Fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies
  • Salted caramel peanut butter pie
  • Banana pudding parfaits

The shared flavours of peanut butter desserts and PB whiskey take the experience over the top.

With the right pairings, peanut butter whiskey cocktails can steal the show as the centrepiece of an entire gourmet menu.

Satisfy Your Cocktail Cravings with Peanut Butter Whiskey

I hope this guide has shown just how versatile peanut butter whiskey can be and inspired you to expand your cocktail repertoire. With its rich, smooth and balanced flavour profile, the possibilities are truly endless.

Here are a few key takeaways as you stock your bar and craft PB whiskey masterpieces:

  • Quality is key – Seek out reputable peanut butter whiskey brands that blend top-shelf base spirits with real peanut butter.
  • Balance flavours – Play around with sweet, savoury and bitter supporting ingredients to keep peanut butter flavours from overpowering.
  • Think beyond basics – Use peanut butter whiskey to elevate classics as well as more indulgent, creative combinations.
  • Pair thoughtfully – Match peanut butter whiskey drinks with complementary food flavours and textures.

The next time you host a cocktail party, be sure to surprise and delight guests with peanut butter whiskey creations. Trust me, they’ll be begging for your recipes by the end of the night!

Now grab a bottle and start shaking – your new favourite cocktail awaits. Cheers!

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Posts

  • The Ultimate Guide to Non-Peaty Whisky

    The Ultimate Guide to Non-Peaty Whisky

    As a dedicated whiskey enthusiast and founder of Best Whiskey Guide, I have spent years exploring the diverse world of Scotch whisky. My fascination with this spirit has led me to taste countless expressions from distilleries across Scotland, and I’m passionate about sharing my knowledge and experiences with fellow whiskey lovers. In this comprehensive guide, I’ll…

    Read more

  • Glenmorangie Signet: A Deep Dive into the Luxurious Single Malt

    Glenmorangie Signet: A Deep Dive into the Luxurious Single Malt

    Glenmorangie Signet is a testament to the distillery’s commitment to pushing the boundaries of what’s possible in the world of single malt scotch. Crafted by the renowned Glenmorangie Distillery, which has been producing exceptional whiskies in the Highlands of Scotland since 1843, Signet represents a departure from the distillery’s signature style and a venture into uncharted territory.…

    Read more

  • Maker’s Mark Whisky Review: A Detailed Analysis

    Maker’s Mark Whisky Review: A Detailed Analysis

    Maker’s Mark is a household name in the bourbon world, known for its distinctive red wax-dipped bottles and smooth, approachable flavour profile. As a wheated bourbon, Maker’s Mark substitutes wheat for the traditional rye grain in its mash bill, resulting in a sweeter, gentler whisky that has captivated enthusiasts for generations. The History of Maker’s…

    Read more