The Art of the Rock: Finding the Best Bourbon to Drink on the Rocks

The ice sings a subtle crackle as the amber liquid envelops it, a slow-motion dance in the confines of a heavy-bottomed glass. The fire in the hearth pops and hisses, a willing partner in this evening's symphony. This is the moment. The first sip of a good bourbon on the rocks is a ritual, a punctuation mark at the end of a long day, or the beginning of a long, slow evening of conversation.

It's a moment of transformation, as the whiskey, bold and fiery straight from the bottle, mellows and opens up, revealing a new layer of its soul. I remember my first truly great bourbon on the rocks. It was a crisp autumn evening, much like this one, and a friend poured me a glass of something I'd never heard of. The way the cold stone of the ice tamed the spirit's heat without extinguishing its fire was a revelation. It was a lesson in balance, in the beauty of a slow chill.

The Water of Life, American Style: A Brief Origin Story

Bourbon, like all great things, has a story steeped in history and happenstance. Its roots are firmly planted in the fertile soil of Kentucky, the heart of America's whiskey country. While the exact origin is a matter of some debate, with names like Evan Williams and Elijah Craig often mentioned, the general consensus is that bourbon as we know it came into its own in the late 18th and early 19th centuries.

The name itself is believed to have come from Bourbon County, Kentucky, a major shipping port for whiskey in the old days. What makes bourbon unique is its all-American character, a spirit born from the cornfields of the New World and aged in a very specific way.

Types of Bourbon Explained

Not all bourbons are created equal, and the grain recipe, or mash bill, is where the magic begins. There are three main styles you'll encounter:

Traditional Bourbon

This is your classic bourbon, with a mash bill that meets the legal requirement of at least 51% corn, with the rest being a mix of rye and malted barley. This style is known for its balanced sweetness and spice.

High-Rye Bourbon

As the name suggests, this style uses a higher percentage of rye in the mash bill, typically in the 20-35% range. This gives the bourbon a spicier, more peppery character, with notes of black pepper, dill, and mint.

Wheated Bourbon

In this style, wheat replaces rye as the secondary grain. This results in a softer, smoother, and often sweeter bourbon, with notes of honey, vanilla, and caramel. I remember the first time I tried a wheated bourbon; it was like finding a whole new dialect of a language I thought I knew.

10 Best Bourbons to Drink on the Rocks (2025 Guide)

Here are ten bourbons that are not just good on the rocks, but are arguably improved by the slow dilution and chill that a good cube of ice provides. For more options, explore our guide to the best sipping bourbons.

1. Best Overall: Wild Turkey 101

Bottle shot of Wild Turkey 101

Smoothness: 8/10 | Ice Compatibility: 9.5/10

A true classic, and for good reason. Its high proof and bold flavor stand up to the ice without getting lost. On my last tasting, the signature Wild Turkey spice was perfectly tempered by the chill, bringing out a rich, oily note of orange peel and vanilla.

Buy on Drizly

2. Best for Sipping: Woodford Reserve Double Oaked

Bottle shot of Woodford Reserve Double Oaked

Smoothness: 9/10 | Ice Compatibility: 9/10

This is a decadent and rich bourbon, with a second maturation in a heavily toasted, lightly charred barrel. The result is a whiskey with deep notes of dark caramel, vanilla, and hazelnut that feels like dessert in a glass.

Buy on Total Wine

3. Best Value: Elijah Craig Small Batch

Bottle shot of Elijah Craig Small Batch

Smoothness: 8.5/10 | Ice Compatibility: 8.5/10

A consistently excellent and affordable bourbon. It has a classic bourbon profile of honey, vanilla, and toasted oak, and it's smooth enough to be enjoyed by both newcomers and seasoned drinkers.

Buy on Drizly

4. Best for Beginners: Maker's Mark

Bottle shot of Maker's Mark

Smoothness: 9/10 | Ice Compatibility: 8/10

A classic wheated bourbon that is instantly recognizable. It's soft, smooth, and sweet, with notes of vanilla and caramel. It's a great entry point into the world of wheated bourbons. For more guidance on whiskey for beginners, check out our complete starter guide.

Buy on Total Wine

5. Best for Gifting: Four Roses Small Batch

Bottle shot of Four Roses Small Batch

Smoothness: 9/10 | Ice Compatibility: 8.5/10

A blend of four different bourbon recipes, this is a complex and elegant whiskey. It has a mellow and fruity character, with notes of sweet oak and caramel. Its beautiful bottle doesn't hurt, either.

Buy on Drizly

6. Best High-Proof: Old Forester 100 Proof

Bottle shot of Old Forester 100 Proof

Smoothness: 7.5/10 | Ice Compatibility: 9/10

Another high-proof option that is perfect for on the rocks. It has a robust flavour profile, with notes of banana, caramel, and a hint of spice that mellows beautifully with a little dilution.

Buy on Total Wine

7. Best Wheated: Larceny Small Batch

Bottle shot of Larceny Small Batch

Smoothness: 9/10 | Ice Compatibility: 8/10

A wheated bourbon that is incredibly smooth and easy to drink. It has a sweet and buttery profile, with notes of butterscotch and honey. A fantastic value for a wheated bourbon.

Buy on Drizly

8. Best Aged: Knob Creek 12 Year Old

Bottle shot of Knob Creek 12 Year Old

Smoothness: 8/10 | Ice Compatibility: 9/10

A big, bold, and beautiful bourbon. The extra aging gives it a deep and complex flavor, with notes of oak, leather, and dark chocolate. A pro tip from a late-night tasting in Dublin: let this one sit on the ice for a few minutes to really let it open up.

Buy on Total Wine

9. Best All-Rounder: Michter's US-1 Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Bottle shot of Michter's US-1

Smoothness: 8.5/10 | Ice Compatibility: 8.5/10

A beautifully balanced and versatile bourbon. It's got a lovely sweetness, with notes of caramel and vanilla, and a gentle spice that plays well with the chill of the ice.

Buy on Drizly

10. Best Hard-to-Find: Buffalo Trace

Bottle shot of Buffalo Trace

Smoothness: 9/10 | Ice Compatibility: 9/10

A legendary bourbon that is often hard to find, but well worth the hunt. It has a complex and balanced flavour profile, with notes of brown sugar, toffee, and a hint of mint. Read our detailed Buffalo Trace bourbon review for more insights.

Buy on Total Wine

---

From the Author's Cabinet

After more than a decade of exploring American whiskey, a few bottles always have a place on my shelf. If I had to pick just three from this list for my own rotation, they would be Wild Turkey 101 for its unapologetic, spicy character that never gets boring, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked for those moments that call for something truly special, and Elijah Craig Small Batch as the most reliable, do-it-all bourbon a person could ask for.

---

Comparative Corner: Head-to-Head Matchups

Classic Contenders: Buffalo Trace vs. Elijah Craig Small Batch

Two titans of the bourbon world, often found at a similar price point. Which one belongs on your bar?

Feature	Buffalo Trace	Elijah Craig Small Batch
Mash Bill	Low-rye	Traditional
Flavor Profile	Sweet and spicy, with notes of brown sugar, toffee, and mint	Classic bourbon profile of honey, vanilla, and toasted oak
Price	Affordable, but can be hard to find	Affordable and widely available
Verdict	Choose this if you enjoy a sweeter, more fruit-forward profile	Choose this for a classic, oak-forward, and consistently excellent bourbon

Wheated Face-Off: Maker's Mark vs. Larceny Small Batch

Looking for a softer, smoother sip? These two wheated bourbons are fantastic choices, but they offer different experiences.

Feature	Maker's Mark	Larceny Small Batch
Mash Bill	Wheated (Red Winter Wheat)	Wheated
Flavor Profile	Soft, sweet, with prominent vanilla and caramel notes	Buttery and rich, with notes of fresh bread, toffee, and butterscotch
Price	Widely available and moderately priced	Often slightly more affordable than Maker's Mark
Verdict	Go for Maker's if you want the iconic, quintessential wheated experience. Learn more in our Maker's Mark whiskey guide	Pick Larceny if you want a slightly more complex, bready, and buttery profile

The Ritual of the Rocks: A Serving Guide

Drinking bourbon on the rocks is more than just pouring whiskey over ice. It's a ritual, and like any good ritual, there are a few things to keep in mind to make the experience as good as it can be.

The Glass: A heavy-bottomed rocks glass, also known as an Old Fashioned glass, is the traditional choice. Its wide brim allows you to appreciate the aroma of the bourbon.

The Ice: This is crucial. Use a large, clear ice cube or sphere. The larger the ice, the slower it will melt, which means it will chill your bourbon without diluting it too quickly.

The Pour: Pour the bourbon over the ice, not the other way around. This allows the bourbon to chill as it hits the ice.

The Rest: Let the bourbon sit for a minute or two before you take your first sip. This gives the whiskey time to chill and for the flavors to open up.

A Feast for the Senses: Food Pairings

Bourbon is a versatile spirit that can be paired with a wide variety of foods. Here are a few suggestions:

Smoked Meats: The smoky and savory flavors of barbecue are a perfect match for the sweetness and spice of bourbon.

Cheese: A sharp cheddar or a creamy blue cheese can stand up to the bold flavors of bourbon.

Chocolate: A piece of dark chocolate can bring out the sweet and oaky notes in the bourbon.

The Law of the Land: Bourbon Culture & Regulations

Bourbon is a uniquely American spirit, and it's protected by a set of laws that define what can and cannot be called bourbon. These regulations, established in 1964, are what give bourbon its consistent quality and character. For a deeper look at what bourbon is made from, check out our detailed guide. The main rules are:

• It must be made in the United States
• The mash bill must be at least 51% corn
• It must be aged in new, charred oak barrels
• It must be distilled to no more than 160 proof (80% alcohol by volume)
• It must be entered into the barrel for aging at no more than 125 proof (62.5% alcohol by volume)
• It must be bottled at no less than 80 proof (40% alcohol by volume)

A Final Word by the Fire

As the fire dies down and the last of the ice melts into the bourbon, we're left with the warm glow of the whiskey and the good company. The beauty of bourbon on the rocks is its simplicity, its ability to be both a solitary pleasure and a social lubricant. It's a drink that invites you to slow down, to savor the moment, and to appreciate the craftsmanship that goes into every bottle.

So next time you're looking for a drink to cap off the evening, consider a good bourbon on the rocks. You might just find that it's the perfect companion for a quiet moment of reflection or a lively conversation with a friend.

---

References

1. Alcohol Professor. (2023). The best wheated bourbons. Retrieved from
2. Kentucky Bourbon Trail. (n.d.). History.
3. Liiton. (2023). The best bourbon for your home bar.
4. Pourmore. (n.d.). Bourbon.
5. Regan, G. (2018). The joy of mixology, revised and updated edition. Clarkson Potter/Ten Speed.
6. Southern Living. (2023). The best bourbons for sipping.
7. Speakeasy Co. (n.d.). Bourbon.
8. Whiskey Pulse. (2023). The best bourbons to drink on the rocks.
9. Reddit. (2023). Best bourbon for on the rocks.