Old Forester 1870 Original Batch: A Deep Dive

Old Forester 1870 Original Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is part of a rich heritage of American whiskey, founded in 1870 by George Garvin Brown. As the first bourbon sold in sealed glass bottles, this innovative approach ensured quality and prevented counterfeiting. For those wondering about what bourbon is made from, Brown’s vision for consistent flavor came from batching whiskey from three different distilleries, establishing a legacy that continues in the Old Forester Whiskey Row Series.

Historical Significance

In 1870, George Garvin Brown established Old Forester on Louisville’s renowned Whiskey Row. Today’s 1870 Original Batch honors this heritage by blending whiskey from three distinct warehouses, with each barrel selected from different production days, entry proofs, and age profiles. For those interested in how whiskey is made, this meticulous approach ensures that each bottle captures the essence of Brown’s original vision.

Production and Distilling

Old Forester is crafted at the Brown–Forman distillery in Shively, Kentucky, under Master Distiller Chris Morris’s guidance. As part of the ultimate guide to Kentucky whiskey, the bourbon uses a distinctive mash bill of 72% corn, 18% rye, and 10% malted barley – the same recipe used for Woodford Reserve. Understanding the differences between whiskey and bourbon helps appreciate the brand’s adherence to bourbon-making traditions.

Tasting Notes and Flavor Profile

For those learning how to taste whiskey like a pro, this 90 proof bourbon (45% ABV) offers a balanced and approachable flavor profile. Among the best sipping bourbons, the resulting blend of spice and fruit is a testament to Brown’s original vision.

Nose

According to Master of Malt, the aroma presents warm clove spiciness intertwined with citrus fruits, notably bright oranges and grapefruits, with a hint of blood orange adding depth. Floral honeysuckle notes add elegance, while hints of spiced shortbread and candied mixed peel provide complexity. Some enthusiasts detect cherry-heavy dried dark fruit, oak, coffee cake, vanilla, brown sugar, and a touch of cinnamon.

Palate

The Whiskey Jug describes a palate rich with baking spices like clove, cinnamon, and nutmeg, complemented by citrus zest and subtle shortbread sweetness. The experience unfolds with layers of caramel and dried dark fruit, while structured oak provides a pleasant dryness. Biscuity notes and maple frosting contribute additional sweetness, with cocoa and baking spice adding warmth and depth.

Finish

Breaking Bourbon notes a soft, lingering finish where fruit and spice gracefully fade. Warm spices persist pleasantly, creating an inviting conclusion that beckons another sip. The medium-length finish offers notes of maple donut, oak, corn, and dried dark fruit.

Reviews and Recognition

Whiskey Consensus rates it 7.8/10, placing it firmly in their “Good” category. Breaking Bourbon commends it as “a bourbon that actually tastes like it smells” with a “delightful mingling of vibrant fruit flavors.”

The bourbon has garnered several prestigious awards, including:

• Double Gold Medal at the 2015 San Francisco World Spirits Competition
• 95 points, “Extraordinary,” Ultimate Recommendation at the 2015 Ultimate Spirits Challenge
• Gold Medal at the 2019 Whiskies of the World
• Master & Taste Master at the 2019 American Whiskey Masters
• Silver Medal at the 2020 International Wine & Spirits Competition

Value and Availability

Available at Total Wine, Binny’s, and Top Shelf Wine and Spirits, this bourbon typically ranges from $45-$55 for a 750ml bottle. In the UK market, it’s available through AMAZON for £51.90.

Conclusion About Old Forester 1870

Old Forester 1870 Original Batch stands as a testament to Brown’s pioneering spirit, offering bourbon enthusiasts a chance to experience a piece of whiskey history while enjoying a well-crafted, balanced spirit. Within the Old Forester Whiskey Row Series, it serves as an excellent entry point for those new to bourbon or seeking a classic, balanced flavor profile.

While it may not reach the complexity of other expressions like 1910 or 1920, it delivers a smooth and enjoyable experience that showcases the core characteristics of Old Forester bourbon. Its historical connection to George Garvin Brown’s original batching process adds another layer of intrigue, making it a compelling choice for whiskey enthusiasts interested in exploring the brand’s rich heritage.